Cholesterol byproduct blocks heart-health benefits of estrogen
DALLAS â€” Sept. 16, 2007 â€” New findings by UT Southwestern Medical Center researchers show that a byproduct of cholesterol metabolism interferes with the beneficial effects estrogen has on the cardiovascular system, providing a better understanding of the interplay between cholesterol and estrogen in heart disease.
The results of the study, available online and in the October issue of the journal Nature Medicine, also may explain why hormone replacement therapy fails to protect some postmenopausal women from heart disease, said Dr. David Mangelsdorf, chairman of pharmacology and senior author of the paper.
The researchers found that in rodents, a molecule called 27-hydroxycholesterol, or 27HC, binds to the same receptors in the blood vessels of the heart to which estrogen binds.
The normal result of this estrogen binding is that blood vessel walls remain elastic and dilated, and damage to the vasculature is repaired, among other heart-protective effects. Other research has shown that postmenopausal women â€” who no longer produce estrogen â€” lose this protective action and become more susceptible to heart disease.Â Â
Based on their animal studies and other experiments, the UT Southwestern researchers determined that when estrogen levels dropped relative to the amount of 27HC circulating in the blood, 27HC reacted and bound to the estrogen receptors in the cardiovascular system and blocked their protective function, primarily by inhibiting the production of nitric oxide. Nitric oxide mediates smooth muscle relaxation in blood vessels, aids cell growth and repair, and prevents thrombosis. Reduced levels of nitric oxide in blood vessels has been linked with high cholesterol and diabetes.
In animals fed a high-fat, high-cholesterol diet, both cholesterol and 27HC levels were elevated.
â€œWe found that 27HC can effectively inhibit estrogen function in vascular tissue by binding to estrogen receptors,â€ said Dr. Mangelsdorf, a Howard Hughes Medical Institute investigator at UT Southwestern.Â Â â€œThis study not only illustrates the damaging effects high cholesterol has on the heart but also supports the notion that the relative levels of 27HC and estrogen in the vasculature are contributing factors to the risk for cardiovascular disease.â€
In normal premenopausal women, the amount of 27HC generated from cholesterol is relatively low compared to the level of estrogen circulating in the blood, leading to enhanced cardiovascular protection. In contrast, when the level of 27HC is higher relative to estrogen, such as during the postmenopausal period or as a consequence of high cholesterol, the researchers speculate that 27HC out-competes estrogen to bind with estrogen receptors, blocking the function of the receptors and resulting in a loss of protection.
â€œThis model may help explain why women are better protected than men from cardiovascular disease until they reach menopause,â€ said Dr. Mangelsdorf, who holds the Doris and Bryan Wildenthal Distinguished Chair in Medical Science.
The findings also may help explain why a large clinical trial that evaluated certain hormone replacement therapies (HRT) in postmenopausal women â€” a component of the 15-year Womenâ€™s Health Initiative â€” had to be halted in 2002 when the hormones appeared to increase a womanâ€™s risk of heart disease.
â€œIn the Womenâ€™s Health Initiative research program, the women who began taking HRT were an average of 13 years postmenopause,â€ Dr. Manglesdorf said. â€œBy the time they started taking this estrogen again, the damage caused by 27HC binding to the estrogen receptors in the cardiovascular system may already have occurred. Once you lose estrogenâ€™s protection for such an extended period of time, you canâ€™t get it back.â€
The researchers also found that 27HC works predominantly on estrogen receptors in the cardiovascular system. When it binds to estrogen receptors in other tissues, such as reproductive tissues, it has no effect on their reproduction-related functions. This property of 27HC makes it a â€œselective estrogen receptor modulator,â€ or SERM, the first such naturally occurring molecule known to exhibit such selectivity.
â€œThis molecule is remarkable in its selectivity for the vasculature,â€ Dr. Mangelsdorf said. â€œThese findings also validate the estrogen receptor as a possible drug target for manufactured SERMs.â€
Other UT Southwestern researchers involved in the study were: lead author Dr. Michihisa Umetani, instructor of pharmacology; Dr. Hideharu Domoto, former postdoctoral researcher in pharmacology; Dr. Andrew Gormley, former postdoctoral research fellow in pediatrics; Ivan S. Yuhanna, senior research associate in pediatrics; Dr. Carolyn Cummins, HHMI research associate in pharmacology; and Dr. Philip W. Shaul, professor of pediatrics. Researchers from the New York University School of Medicine and the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences also contributed.
The work was supported by the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, the Robert A. Welch Foundation and the National Institutes of Health.Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â