FierceBiotechFierceBioResearcherFierceVaccinesFiercePharma   FierceHealthcare
About | Sample | Privacy

Positive data more likely to find its way to public

There's been a growing understanding in the drug development world that studies boasting of positive data on a drug tend to get published in the scientific literature with great fanfare; negative studies are often silently allowed to sink out from sight. Now a new report in the New England Journal of Medicine concludes how that trend has played out in the antidepressant field. Ninety-four percent of studies with positive drug data showed up in print, compared to 14 percent of the studies with negative or inconclusive results. And that has skewed the reported effectiveness of the drugs. If you combine the negative studies on antidepressants they were able to outperform placebos by only a modest amount, not the 60 percent in published trials that demonstrated a positive response.

That's not likely to be news to practitioners in the field. Antidepressants have long been notoriously unreliable. But it's, well, depressing, to see developers have been gaming the system with such indifference to the scientific pursuit of the truth. Could they have been more interested in making a marketing case for a drug? Need you ask?

- read the article in the New York Times

Related Articles:
Study: Antidepressant warnings work. Report
Top 10 drug warnings and recalls of 2007: Antidepressants

More stories about New England Journal of Medicine   sales and marketing   pharmaceuticals  

Comments

Given the magnitude of placebo response for depression, this is hardly suprising. About a half of all trials could _never_ differentiate from placebo because the placebo response was so large and the drug effect not additive. The skill is to know when to stop such "failed" trials early.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

More information about formatting options

What is 4 + 47?
To combat spam, please solve the math question above.